Like many things related to bowhunting, the choice of broadhead is heavily opinion based and the options are numerous. For every style, there are many brands pushing their own version with unique patented technologies. The best broadhead will, ultimately, be a personal preference. However, the best broadhead should most certainly be durable, made of quality materials such as steel and aluminum, shoot accurately, and penetrate deep. Keep in mind that even the most prestigious broadhead may require tuning to get the most out of it, and this is a perfectly normal expectation. Some brands boast minimal to no tuning, especially for mechanical broadheads. When choosing the best broadhead for you, consider the type of game you’ll be hunting, whether or not you’ll be practicing with your broadheads, and what your price point is.
Top 10 Broadheads for 2017
Fixed Blade/ Mechanical
Top 5 Best Broadheads of 2017
Whether you are looking for the best mechanical broadhead or the best fixed blade broadhead, the top five has it all. Fixed blades, chisel tips, cut-on-contact, mechanical, and more. These reviews will provide all the specifications necessary to make a decision on which are the best broadheads for your hunting needs.
1) G5 Montec Broadhead
Ranking number one, it is no surprise that G5’s Montec is the best fixed blade broadhead. This is the broadhead that made G5 a reality and changed the design of tips. Entirely stainless steel it is a one piece fixed blade head created by metal injection molding. At the time of inception in the early 2000s it was the first of its kind to be entirely one piece stainless steel and that was a big deal. Fast forward to present and it is still a hugely popular and highly regarded broadhead for hunting. The Montec wasn’t a fad or a fleeting craze. It is a tried and true and reliable to the core.
Montec Broadhead Construction
With three razor sharp blades and a cut-on-contact design, the broadhead cuts through fur and flesh with ease. Penetration won’t be a problem and clean straight-through shots with this tip are likely. Cutting diameter is between 1” and 1-⅛” and leaves a nice wide blood trail. It is capable of taking down bears, hogs, and even zebra; but it is by far the best broadhead for deer and one of the best broadheads for elk. 100% spin tested and entirely stainless steel, they are incredibly accurate and fly very similar to field tips.
The durable tapered blades and one piece molding is what makes this tip strong and able to withstand multiple uses. While the blades are not replaceable, they are incredibly easy to sharpen. They are angled at 60 degrees and a couple strokes against a flat whetstone will have them honed again in no time.
G5 Montec Broadhead Conclusion
Precise, sharp, reliable, easy to install, and easy to sharpen. This is everything a great broadhead should be and everything that makes Montec the best flying fixed blade broadhead. Given how expensive broadheads are, it’s reasonable to be hesitant to practice with the real deal. That’s why G5 offers a pre-season version of the Montec. Just another reason why Montec is number one.
2) Carbon Express XT 4-Blade Broadhead, 100 Grain
Carbon Express XT 4-Blade are super sturdy and tough for those after a long lasting broadhead to practice and hunt with. The one piece construction, fixed blades, and cut-on-contact style won’t disappoint in performance. The two main blades are solid at 0.058” thickness and the two thinner bleeder blades lend sharp support in rending through fur. The cutting diameter is 1 ⅛” and the curved blades make for even greater penetration and result in easy to follow blood trails.
The main blades cannot be replaced, but they recover well after being sharpened again. It is also recommended to sharpen them out of the package. The bleeder blades are replaceable and much more difficult to sharpen due to their small size. For this reason, it is wise to take care while practicing to prevent unnecessary damage to the bleeder blades. The main blades, however, can take a beating and are known to stand up to rigorous practice shots.
Final Thoughts on the XT-4 Blade Broadhead
The accuracy is comparable to any great broadhead and many say they are just like field tips. First time hunters have come home with a harvested deer using the XT 4-Blade. Time after time successful hunts are reported, attributed in some small part to this broadhead choice, and goes to show that it’s among the best fixed blade broadheads.
3) Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead
If you are looking for the best mechanical broadhead, this just might be it. Rage is known for their precision manufacturing and state of the art quality checks. This leads to a consistent and quality product. The Hypodermic Standard Broadhead is no exception to that.
How It Works
This aerodynamic broadhead flies like a field tip and blows through the target with ease. With a one piece stainless ferrule and two mechanical blades this is a sturdy and devastating choice. What makes it truly unique are the Rage technologies that go into the design. The Hypodermic isn’t a run of the mill mechanical broadhead. It is a hybrid style that combines the cut-on-contact benefits with an aggressive chisel tip. Rage’s rear blade deployment and Shock Collar system ensures that the chisel punches through bones and the blades trigger at just the right moment for the most effective cutting. This technology is why it is the best expandable broadhead. The blades are 0.035” thick and the diameter can be up to 2”, leaving ridiculous entry and exits points, and the blood trails are impressive. The large diameter makes these the best turkey broadhead, too.
Rage Hypodermic Broadhead Wrapup
As a rule, mechanical heads don’t usually have as much penetration as fixed. However, this tip has gone through two ribs and exited to continue through a log and into the dirt. Truly outstanding and one of the best broadheads for deer class game and the best penetrating broadhead.
Included free the Hypodermic Standard comes with a practice tip to prepare hunters and get sighted properly. Generally no tuning is required, but some bows may need tweaks and sight adjustments for the best accuracy.
4) Stinger 2 Blade Arrow Broadhead
Simple and elegant at a glance, the Stinger 2 Blade Broadhead delivers a lot of oomph in an unassuming form. Don’t let the subtle design fool you into discrediting what is the most versatile and best 2 blade broadhead.
Important Info on the Stinger 2 Blade
The fixed cut-on-contact blades are made from knife-grade stainless steel, tipped with diamond, and can be sharpened when they become dull. Or, if preferred, they are removable and can easily be replaced. Straight out of the package they are lethal sharp, spin tested, and ready to go with minimal tuning necessary. Unlike other options that are completely steel, the Stinger’s ferrule is made of aircraft quality aluminum. Durable and heavy these will last any hunter a long while. Should the product break Magnus will replace the broadhead with their lifetime guarantee, regardless of how the damage was incurred. This makes them a great budget option, perfect for practicing without the worry of accidental damage, and is one reason they are among the best fixed broadheads.
Stinger 2 Blade Conclusion
The penetration is mighty enough to take down moose and bear, which are dangerous game. The bone splitting and true flying design inspire enough confidence to tackle such big prey. This makes them easily one of the best broadhead for elk. Despite their simple design these are magnificent broadheads, especially for the price.
5) Muzzy 100 Grain 4 Screw In Blade
Muzzy’s 100 Grain 4 Screen in Blade is an absolute steal and a reputable broadhead for any hunter. What Muzzy knows is that even the best broadheads won’t fly exactly like a field tip, no matter how close they come to it. This is why they design their broadhead with four removable fixed blades. In a matter of seconds an archer can switch from hunting broadhead to practice broadhead by simply removing the locking blades from the ferrule. Even if you decide to leave the blades on for practice and end up damaging one there are still five more heads for the hunt. That’s because this package comes with six heads for what is typically the price of three.
The combination of a Trocar chisel tip and four hardened steel blades means that these broadheads will cleanly go through a deer with the proper aim and force. The 1” cutting diameter and 0.020” blade thickness is plenty to get the job done and makes them one of the best broadheads for deer. These are a simple and standard solution to broadheads and their popularity proves it. Many customers stand by Muzzy and have used their broadheads for years. Even at number five, these are some of the best fixed blade broadheads available.
Other Great Broadhead Options
Best Broadhead Brands of 2017
1) G5 Outdoors
G5 Outdoors has roots in the 1960s as part of a three generation family owned engineering business. But it wasn’t until the early 2000’s that G5 itself came into existence. Lou Grace patented his all-steel broadhead design and within a year created G5 with his family to bring it to the market. By 2001 the popular and widely known Montec broadhead was introduced and, as the first of its kind, changed the industry. It quickly became one of the best fixed blade broadheads on the market and the best crossbow broadhead, too.
Since 2001 G5 has been growing its offerings with sights, rests, quivers, and a line of Quest bows. On top of that, they’re known for patenting the parallel cam system. G5’s mission is to make bowhunters more effective in the field and their motto reflects that: “Designed to hunt.” The constant innovations, quality gear, and breakthrough technology makes G5 Outdoors a relevant brand in an industry continuously making strides forward. Check Out G5 Broadheads on Amazon.
2) Carbon Express
Carbon Express specializes in arrows and the best broadheads. The technology they employ while designing and manufacturing their products is top of the line and guarantees consistency. Everything is precisely measured and weighed before being shipped. Standing behind their products, Carbon Express has superb customer service. They acknowledge defective products and willingly replace them as needed. Great products combined with great care. Check Out Carbon Express Broadheads on Amazon.
Rage is dedicated primarily to creating the best mechanical broadheads and it shows in their popularity and strength as a brand. Mechanical tips, in particular, are what Rage is best known for thanks to their SlipCam design and ShockLock technology. They’re inventive and game changing products combined with consistent quality is what garners brand loyal customers. With some of the best expandable broadheads on the market, you can’t go wrong with Rage. Check Out Rage Broadheads on Amazon.
4) Magnus Outdoors
Magnus provides a stellar line of cut-on-contact broadheads to meet the needs of their customers. And their customers is what Magnus is all about. Their highest priorities are quality products and quality customer care. Taking care of the customer by producing the best gear, providing the best service, and developing unique products are the principles Magnus stands by. To prove this, they offer a lifetime guarantee with replacements on their merchandise. Magnus is a leader in cut-on-contact broadheads and the performance and versatility of their tips attest to it. Some of the best flying fixed blade broadheads are among Magnus’ lineup. Check Out Magnus Broadheads on Amazon.
Muzzy, as a company, has a powerful mission. They declare to manufacture only products that are unique, superior, or equal to the best products. And that those products will both enhance the hunter’s chance for success and be created with respect for the animals being hunted. Not only do they have quality compound broadheads, but they also produce some of the best crossbow broad heads. Check Out the Lineup of Muzzy Broadheads on Amazon.
Factors for Selecting a Great Broadhead
Above all else, the biggest factor to consider is what type of broadhead suits your needs. This then leads to asking how many blades, what kind of tip, and should it be mechanical? The physical size of the broadhead and the cutting diameter are also important and the game being hunted may affect this variable. The grain, or weight, should be considered as well. The materials play a big part in durable and long lasting heads with enduring sharpness. Each of the qualities should be deliberated before purchase.
For low poundage bows and maximum flesh slicing it is recommended to go with a fixed blade cut-on-contact tip with only a couple blades. However, with a higher draw weight and enough force the best mechanical broadhead will be a great choice and provide plenty of penetration to get through fur and bones. There are a lot of tip and blade variations to play with and it doesn’t hurt to try them all.
Number of Blades
Sometimes simple is better. Having two main blades is just as viable as four blades or two blades and two bleeders. It’s a matter of taste. Some prefer four blades for extra slicing, others find two or three blades to be adequate.
The overall size of the broadhead can make a difference in how much force is needed for optimal penetration. A more compact broadhead is good for lower draw weight bows and building enough energy to penetrate deep into deer class game. Whereas larger blades will create a bigger cutting diameter and possibly create larger blood trails to follow.
A good sturdy broadhead will usually be made of stainless steel or aluminum or some combination. Some of the sharpest and most impressive broadheads are made from carbon steel, although this material has the drawback of rusting and degrading due to the mixed in iron. Also be aware of whether or not your broadhead is one piece or not, as this may affect the durability.
Most broadheads range from 85 to 150 grain. Choose the grain that best suits your needs and shooting style. Typically, the best crossbow broadhead is 100 to 125 grain.
Different Types of Broadheads
There are a variety of types of broadhead tips. Some perform better than others in particular situations, but all are relevant and popular choices for hunters. Tip preference is an opinion and not a mandate. There isn’t a one size fits all broadhead for everyone, but there’s enough diversity to satisfy the needs and styles of any archer. It is no secret that best broadhead for deer are usually 1” up to 1-½” cutting diameter. Whereas larger tips are suitable for birds and smaller game with easier to penetrate bodies.
The cut-on-contact style, combined with fixed blades, is a preferable option for hunters with slower bows. Due to the incredibly sharp blades, this broadhead will literally cut and rend. It slices through the fur and meat and, while it may not penetrate as far as other types, is lethal in the right places. They are recommended for bows with a lower draw weight due to the fact they are effective even with minimal force behind them. Take a Look At Cut-on-Contact Broadheads on Amazon.
Chisel tip style is nearly the opposite of cut-on-contact. The purpose of the chisel tip is to puncture, penetrate, and tear through bones with considerable force driving it. While it may have blades, the tip itself has a signature “chisel” design that makes contact first and decimates whatever is in its path. Often, a good shot made with a chisel tip will result in the arrow going straight through the game and exiting. The durable design of the chisel tip broadhead means they are highly reusable and can endure going through bone and dashing against rocks. Check out Chisel Tip Broadheads on Amazon.
Fixed blade broadheads have a variety of sub-styles to consider. As a whole, fixed blade refers to the fact that the blades are firmly set and do not adjust or expand, as would be found in mechanical blades. The blades can either be sharpened when they grow dull or some models will have replaceable blades.
The number of blades should also be considered. They come in two blade, three blade, and four blade varieties. The number used comes down to preference and experience. There are also smaller “bleeder” blades that can be found on some broadheads, sometimes contributing to the total count of blades. Regardless of blade number, the best fixed broadhead will be sturdy and cut deep into the target. Check Out Fixed Blade Broadheads on Amazon.
Mechanical broadheads, also called expandable, are a solution to a problem that has plagued broadhead tips for a long time. When practicing, the bow is tuned and sighted for field tips, which are less expensive and don’t have blades. However, when hunting it is the broadheads that are in the quiver. These are a little heavier and their different shape changes the way the arrow shoots. Many traditional broadheads require that the bow be tuned to them or the sights adjusted to compensate. The best mechanical broadheads change the game by keeping the blades tucked into the ferrule while the arrow is knocked. The blades then deploy during contact with the target. This means the arrow flies like a field tip but penetrates and tears as a broadhead. The design eliminates a lot of the inconsistency between using a field tip and a broad head. Take a look at Mechanical Broadheads on Amazon.
Having the best compound bow and gear should be complemented with an equally fantastic broadhead. After all, the broadhead is most intimately engaged with the target and is responsible for delivering the killing blow and leaving a trackable blood trail. Selecting the right head for your bow, style, and game, is crucial and just as important as any of the other equipment. You want it to be sharp, precise, lethal, durable, and packing a punch that will take down anything from a turkey to a moose.